If you just finished binging Our Guild’s Idol and need another webtoon to obsess over, finding the right match can be tricky.
The story stands out because it blends two distinct worlds: MMORPG guild culture and secret idol romance.
Ajin trying to protect Bloomie’s hidden identity while running a guild creates a unique mix of online gaming banter, secret identity tropes, and slow-burn romantic tension.
Whether you are here for the online gaming guild dynamic or the hidden pop-star drama, here are 5 top-tier webtoons that capture that same spark—with clear genre notes so you know exactly what to expect.
1. My Love Story with Yamada-kun at Lv999
- Genre: Romance, Comedy, Slice of Life (Shoujo/Josei)
- Key Match: MMORPG Guild Culture, In-Game to Real-Life Romance
- Where to Read: Mangamo / ComicSMART
The Gaming Hook
If your favorite part of Our Guild’s Idol is watching guild members interact online before meeting in person, this is an absolute must-read.
After her boyfriend dumps her for another girl he met in an online game, Akane logs into the MMORPG Forest of Savior to vent her frustration.
There, she meets Yamada, a quiet, legendary pro gamer in her guild who is famously uninterested in romance.
What starts as casual guild events quickly turns into a sweet, realistic romance as their online lives bleed into real-world meetups.
Must Read -> 5 Dark Thriller Manhwa Like Bunker Days You Need to Read Next
2. Your Smile Is a Trap
- Genre: Romance, Comedy, High School
- Key Match: Secret Idol Identity, Misunderstood Lead
- Where to Read: WEBTOON
The Secret Identity Angle
For readers who love Bloomie hiding his pop-star identity in Our Guild’s Idol, Your Smile Is a Trap delivers a delightfully charming take on the same concept.
An Lily is a former star idol trainee whose face is so strikingly handsome that it constantly causes chaos.
Desperate to make real friends and live an ordinary life, he puts on thick glasses and disguises himself at a new high school.
He ends up sitting next to Cha Cha-u, a girl whose tough glare scares everyone away despite her soft heart. Watching Lily struggle to hide his idol habits while navigating normal school life is pure comedy.
Must Read -> 5 Dark Thriller Manhwa Like Bunker Days You Need to Read Next
3. The Guild Member Next Door (Virtual Strangers)
- Genre: BL Romance, Comedy, MMORPG
- Key Match: MMORPG Guild Raids, Unknowing Next-Door Neighbors
- Where to Read: Lezhin / Official Comic Portals
The Guild & Neighbor Conflict
Note: This is a Boys’ Love (BL) webtoon, but its portrayal of MMORPG guild mechanics is among the most accurate in the genre.
Lee Yeo-woon (playing as “Neutaaaa”) joins the popular fantasy MMORPG Illusion and gets recruited into a top guild.
In-game, high-ranking guildmate “Ji9star” (Yoon Ji-gu) acts overly protective and pushy.
In real life, Ji-gu happens to be Yeo-woon’s grumpy next-door neighbor.
Neither realizes that the person they argue with in the apartment hallway is the same guildmate they rely on during late-night raids.
4. Lost in Translation
- Genre: Drama, Romance, Music Industry
- Key Match: K-Pop Idol Pressures, Fake Persona vs. True Self
- Where to Read: WEBTOON
Behind the K-Pop Persona
Bloomie in Our Guild’s Idol carries immense pressure to maintain his public image.
Lost in Translation takes a deeper, more grounded look at what happens when a star’s public persona is completely fabricated.
Jaewon (stage name Wyld) is a member of the top boy group Mayhem.
To generate media buzz, his management forces him to act like a toxic “bad boy” in news outlets.
In reality, Jaewon is gentle and deeply protective of his teammates. The series handles idol culture, media toxicity, and genuine connection with real care.
5. Debut or Die
- Genre: Idol Survival, Drama, System Fantasy
- Key Match: High-Stakes Idol Industry & Group Dynamics
- Where to Read: Tapas / KakaoPage
The High-Stakes Idol Ecosystem
If you want to dive deeper into the mechanics of the K-pop industry and how idol groups build their fanbases, Debut or Die is one of the most acclaimed webtoons in the space.
Park Moondae wakes up in the body of a young man with a system message giving him a strict ultimatum: debut as an idol within a year or die.
To survive, he enters a competitive idol survival program. It gives a fascinating, tactical look at voting fanbases, group rivalries, and stage performances.
Summary Recommendation Matrix
- Want MMORPG Guild Romance (BG)? → Read My Love Story with Yamada-kun at Lv999
- Want Cute Secret Idol Romance? → Read Your Smile Is a Trap
- Want Guild Raids & Real-Life Clashes (BL)? → Read The Guild Member Next Door
- Want Realistic Idol Industry Drama? → Read Lost in Translation
[…] 5 Best Webtoons Like Our Guild’s Idol You Need to Read Next […]